The agent forms the intention at one time either by making an explicit conscious decision to perform the action or by some less deliberate, more automatic, process. Intention, plans, and practical reason, center for the study of language and information bratman, michael. Bratman 2009b the basic problem is that one might believe that one intends m and yet not in fact intend m. Intentions are treated as elements of partial plans of action. My book publications are intention, plans, and practical reason 1987, faces of intention. These plans play basic roles in practical reasoning, roles. Bratmans counterexample is not supposed to dispute the idea that we often act intentionally with an intention to so act. In the second, i describe one aspect of his solution an appeal to widescope norms of practical rationality and. At the heart of the model of plans lies a simple idea.
Evaluating agent\u27s rationality is not just a matter of evaluating the agent\u27s reasons for acting at the moment of a decision. These plans play basic roles in practical reasoning. Belief, intention, intentional action, and the simple view. Michael bratman, intention, plans, and practical reason. Bratman explores the impact of this approach on a wide range of issues, including the relation between intention and intentional action, and. In such a case ones beliefs might be coherent even though ones plans remain meansend incoherent. Agency is sometimes exercised in concert, as when we walk together, several individuals undertake painting a house, or a football team executes a pass play. The content of a plan, shapiro says, is fixed by social facts about the adoption and acceptance of the plan. Note that these two ideas, taken together, still do not entail that an intention to a actually requires a belief that one will a. Intention involves desire, but even predominant desire is insufficient for intention, since it need not involve a commitment to act.
By continuing to use our website, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Note that these two ideas, taken together, still do not. Bratman formulates two weaker versions of this kind of. Michael bratman, intention, plans, and practical reason cambridge. Then, unless it is revised, the intention will lead the agent to perform the action directly. Its rationality follows from the rationality of intending to read my manuscript. Intention, plans, and practical reason david hume series. I shall call this the bootstrapping objection, in honour of michael bratman, who raises it in his intentions, plans and practical reason.
And, indeed, there is reason to reject such a purported connection between intention and belief as overly strong. Response to bratman 2005, which constituted his very thoughtful and helpful. Bratman explores the impact of this approach on a wide range of issues, including the relation between intention and inte michael e. Similar to other authors, bratman stresses the the role of intention in a hierarchical and forwardmoving structure of desire, intent and planning. Intention, plans, and practical reason stanford university web. Intention, practical rationality, and selfgovernance michael. Two faces of intention michael bratman we do things intentionally, and we intend to do things. Action intention and reason download pdfepub ebook. Suppose you are wondering whether to visit paris, but have not yet made. For this terminology see intention, plans, and practical reason. Our commonsense psychology uses the notion of intention to characterize both our actions and our mental states. Intention, plans and practical reason by michael e.
This important contribution to the philosophy of action is the culminationthough not in any sense a compilationof michael bratmans numerous studies on the nature and function of intentional with the excep. Bratmans idea is that, given my bridge intention, the norms of consistency and coherence governing my individual intentions will be recruited to require that i form my plans and intentions with an eye toward consistency and coherence with your plans and intentions. Intention, belief, practical, theoretical michael e. My main research interests are in the philosophy of action, where this includes issues about social agency and about practical rationality. Donagan discusses one of theseconcerning the consistency demands to which intentions are subjectin choice, pp. Michael bratmans restricted twotier approach to rationalizing the stability of intentions contrasts with an alternative view of planning, for which all of the following claims are made. Intention, plans, and practical reason stanford university. In actions, reasons and causes, donald davidson gave a reductive theory of intention with which as syncategorematic. Readings moral psychology linguistics and philosophy. It is hardly controversial that there really is a phenomenon falling under labels such as shared activity, and joint or collective action.
Bratman s theory of intentions as plans has also led to a distinctive and widely discussed account of collective intentionality. Bratman is published by center for the study of language and information. Me bratman, intention, plans, and practical reason jstor. Much work in the philosophy of action in the last few decades has focused on the elucidation and justification of a series of purported norms of practical rationality that concern the presence or absence of intention in light of belief, and that demand a kind of structural coherence in the psychology of an agent.
The puzzle it poses a puzzle, which bratman describes. The traditional ontological problem and the intention thesis. Two faces of intention ecole nationale superieure des. The guiding principle of this book is that intention and related phenomena are best understood as manifestations of the human capacity to plan and coordinate. If it available for your country it will shown as book reader and user fully subscribe will.
Pdf intention, plans, and practical reason semantic scholar. Intention, practical rationality, and selfgovernance. Cambridge university press, 1999 brought to everyones attention the importance of plans, general intentions, etc. Harvard, 1987 and intention, practical rationality, and selfgovernance, unpublished. I might inten tionally start my car, and i might intend to start it. These plans play basic roles in practical reasoning, roles that support the organization of our activities over time and socially.
In the first, i sketch a puzzle about reason and intention that motivates bratmans 1987 book, intention, plans, and practical reason. This paper reconstructs the theory of dynamic rationality sketched by michael bratman in intention, plans, and practical reason. For an alternative view that tries to accommodate intentions within a beliefdesire framework, see. Bratman, intention, plans, and practical reason, 28. Plans and resourcebounded practical reasoning, computational intelligence 4, pp. A planning theory of acting together 2014 and planning, time, and selfgovernance. Rational constraints and the simple view analysis oxford. Bratman explores the impact of this approach on a wide range of issues, including the relation between intention and intentional action, and the distinction between intended and expected effects of what one intends.
Intention, plans, and practical reason david hume series bratman, michael e. The book intention, plans and practical reason, michael e. Intention plans and practical reason pdf what happens to our conception of mind and rational agency when we take seriously futuredirected intentions and plans and their roles as. Welcome,you are looking at books for reading, the action intention and reason, you will able to read or download in pdf or epub books and notice some of author may have lock the live reading for some of country. Of all published articles, the following were the most read within the past 12 months. On first view, reading manuscript need not be separately rationalized.
Intention, plans and practical reason the david hume series. Michael bratman, intention, plans, and practical reason philpapers. Planning and the stability of intention springerlink. Therefore it need a free signup process to obtain the book. Jan 01, 1987 these plans play basic roles in practical reasoning, roles that support the organization of our activities over time and socially. Bratman the planning theory of intention and of our agency highlights the fundamental coordinating and organizing roles of structures of planning in the temporally extended and social practical thought and action of agents like us. Intention, plans, and practical reason michael bratman.
The volitive and the executive function of intentions. My detailed treatment of choice differs in certain ways from donagans. Michael bratmans intention, plans, and practical reason new york. Acting on an intention 69 ii consider two possible defences of the suggestion that it is rational for you to read my manuscript. Intention, plans and practical reason the david hume. The idea that there are standards of practical reason apart from or independent of good character, kieran setiya 2007a. Bratmans theory of intentions as plans has also led to a distinctive and widely discussed account of collective intentionality. Bratman stanford university abstract in my 1987 book i tried to understand intentions as, in the basic case, elements of larger and typically partial plans whose primary roles in our lives are ones of coordination and organization, both crosstemporal and social. Intention, plans, and practical reason cambridge, mass harvard university press, 1987. Of course, there are various differences in our views. Bratman 32117 forthcoming with possible small changes in the routledge handbook of practical reason, edited by ruth chang and kurt sylvan.
Selected essays on intention and agency 1999, structures of agency. Review of intention, plans, and practical reason, by michael bratman. Intention, plans, and practical reason in searchworks catalog. Many have found the following beliefintention principle plausible.
Setiya on intention, rationality and reasons analysis. For bratman 1987, intention is a distinctive practical attitude marked by its pivotal role in planning for the future. Intention, practical rationality, and selfgovernance michael e. I learned from michael bratmansintention, plans and practical reason 3 that you cannot bootstrap a reason into existence like this. The just given justification of the twofunction thesis is a practical justification.
When we have a shared intention to j, where j is a joint activity, then we each have intentions that we j. Belief, intention, intentional action, and the simple view je. Early intentions are crossvalued with internal, and more interestingly external constraints and result in more practical intentions, closer related to actions. Simplifying somewhat, the core of bratmans account is this. And in this respect, which is the only one relevant here, the counterexample succeeds by mccanns own admission. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading intention, plans and practical reason the david hume series.
489 242 2 258 599 191 632 390 743 848 394 123 493 652 390 303 906 1469 1477 15 122 1098 483 315 999 203 696 383 40 1257 108 1023 401 1414 761 685 995 865 1390 730 735 734 1483 1267 1310